The Enduring Legacy of the Buffalo Nickel: Why Collectors Still Treasure this Iconic Coin
Few coins capture the spirit of America’s past as powerfully as the Buffalo Nickel. Struck from 1913 to 1938, this beloved five-cent piece has become one of the most iconic coins in U.S. history—cherished not just for its artistry, but for the story it tells about a changing nation.
A Design That Defined an Era
Designed by sculptor James Earle Fraser, the Buffalo Nickel broke away from the plain, classical motifs of earlier U.S. coinage. Instead, it celebrated the rugged identity of the American West:
-
The Obverse (Front): A composite portrait of three Native American leaders, symbolizing strength, dignity, and the deep cultural heritage of America’s first peoples.
-
The Reverse (Back): A powerful American bison, commonly believed to be modeled after “Black Diamond,” a buffalo from the Bronx Zoo.
This imagery gave the coin a bold, unmistakable character. Unlike most coins of its day, the Buffalo Nickel was instantly recognizable—even after years of circulation wear.
Type 1 and Type 2
When the Buffalo Nickel debuted in 1913, it was struck in two distinct varieties: Type 1 and Type 2. The Type 1 Buffalo Nickel features the bison standing on a raised mound, with the words FIVE CENTS prominently displayed but prone to wear. Later that same year, the Mint modified the design to create the Type 2 Buffalo Nickel, placing the bison on a flat line or exergue and recessing the denomination for greater durability. Collectors prize both types, with Type 1 nickels admired for their bold, original design and Type 2 nickels valued for their historical role in solving the coin’s production challenges.
Why They Matter to Collectors
Buffalo Nickels hold a special place in numismatics for several reasons:
Historical Resonance – The coin bridges America’s frontier past with its industrial future. Struck during the early 20th century, it reflects a nation grappling with modernization while honoring its heritage.
Artistic Innovation – Fraser’s design marked a turning point in U.S. coinage, pushing toward more sculptural and meaningful artwork. Today, many consider it one of the finest examples of American coin design.
Rarity and Variety – The series is full of fascinating varieties, such as the famous 1916 Doubled Die, the 1918/7-D Overdate, and the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo. These rarities spark excitement among collectors and add depth to the hunt.
Accessibility – Unlike some classic coins, Buffalo Nickels are approachable for beginners. Circulated examples are affordable, while higher-grade or rare varieties appeal to advanced collectors. This dual appeal makes them an ideal “gateway coin” into numismatics.
More Than Just Money
Beyond their metallic value, Buffalo Nickels symbolize America’s complex identity. They remind us of indigenous heritage, wildlife preservation, and the frontier mythos—all struck into a humble five-cent piece that passed through countless hands during the Great Depression and beyond.
The Collector’s Takeaway
Buffalo Nickels aren’t just collectible—they’re conversation pieces, works of art, and tangible pieces of history. Whether you’re chasing elusive varieties or simply holding one worn smooth from decades of use, you’re touching a coin that has inspired generations of numismatists.
For many collectors, the Buffalo Nickel is more than a coin—it’s a legend.
Shop our Nickel Collection to add to your collection today!
Learn more: